September 7th, 2009
Geertz, “an eye at once cold and concerned”
I’m reading Available Light: Anthropological Reflections on Philosophical Topics by Clifford Geertz. I have read only the first two chapters. I am moved by it.
It’s been a long time since I last read Geertz, and when I did, I loved his facility with both words and thought. The man can write, but more importantly, he can think while doing it.
Here he is from chapter two:
“…to judge without understanding constitutes an offense against morality.”
“To engage in that style of thinking called social scientific is to attempt to transcend the logical gap that separates them by a pattern of conduct, which, enfolding them into a unitary experience, rationally connects them.”
“In the field, the anthropologist has to learn to live and think at the same time.”
“As I have suggested, this learning process can advance only so far, even under the best of conditions, which anyhow never obtain. The anthropologist inevitably remains more alien than he desires and less cerebral than he imagines. But it does enforce, day in and day out, the effort to advance it, to combine two fundamental orientations toward reality—the engaged and the analytic—into a single attitude. It is this attitude, not moral blankness, which we call detachment or disinterestedness. And whatever small degree of it one manages to attain comes not by adopting an I-am-camera ideology or by enfolding oneself in layers of methodological armor, but simply by trying to do, in such an equivocal situation, the scientific work one has come to do. And as the ability to look at persons and events (and at oneself) with an eye at once cold and concerned is one of the surest signs of maturity in either an individual or a people, this sort of research experience has rather deeper, and rather different, moral implications for our culture than those usually proposed.”
“The professional ethic rests on the personal and draws its strength from it; we force ourselves to see out of a conviction that blindness—or illusion—cripples virtue as it cripples people.”


Leave a Reply